Professional wrestling career
Ohio Valley Wrestling (2009-2012)
Shay made her OVW debut on December 30, 2009 in a singles match won by CJ Lane. On January 30, 2010 at OVW Surviving The Steel, Shay wrestled a triple threat match defeating CJ Lane and Epiphany. At OVW Retribution held on February 28, Taryn teamed with CJ Lane and Epiphany in a six-woman tag team match won by Josette Bynum and the Blossom Sisters (Hannah Blossom & Holly Blossom). On the September 8 edition of OVW, Shay had her first title shot in a dark match won by the champion Josette Bynum. Shay saw another title opportunity wrestling during the May 14, 2011 OVW Saturday Night Special, in an eight-woman gauntlet match won by defending OVW Women's Champion Lady JoJo. By December 28, 2011, Shay earned one more title opportunity when she wrestled for the OVW Women's Championship in a title match won by defending champion Taeler Hendrix. On January 7, 2012, Shay had her title rematch against Hendrix however, she was unsuccessful in winning the title.
Independent circuit (2010-2012)
On September 9, 2010, Shay wrestled for Classic Championship Wrestling in a singles match won by Evilyn. On September 12, 2010, Shay had her first title match losing to defending CCW Women's Champion Cherry Bomb. On September 30, 2011, Shay made her debut in the Phoenix Wrestling Federation at PWF Apocalypse, where she defeated Sojournor Bolt. Shay returned on April 21, 2012 at PWF Nemesis, defeating Lil' Naughty. On August 9, 2012, Shay wrestled at a Juggalo Championship Wrestling event where she lost a match to Sojournor Bolt. On December 7, 2012, Shay made her debut in the United States Wrestling Organization, teaming with Mary Kelly in a tag team match won by D'Arcy Dixon & Miss Rachel.
As of December 7, 2012, Shay has not wrestled any recent matches.
- Teams and stables