The following is the title history of the SHINE Nova Championship.
Priscilla Kelly (July 17, 2016-March 10, 2018)[]
- Defeated Candy Cartwright in tournament finals to become the inaugural champion (SHINE 44)
- Defeated Stormie Lee (FIP Heatstroke 2017)
- Defeated Jordynne Grace (WWR The Show Must Go On)
- Defeated Jordynne Grace (SHINE 45)
- Defeated Candy Cartwright (Style Battle #01.07)
- Defeated Santana Garrett (SHINE 46)
- Defeated Aja Perera (SHINE 47)
- Defeated ACR (FIP Everything Burns 2018)
Candy Cartwright (March 10, 2018-February 11, 2018)[]
- Defeated Priscilla Kelly to become the new champion. (SHINE 49)
- Defeated Priscilla Kelly by Disqualification (SHINE 50
- Defeated Santana Garrett by Disqualification (SHINE 51
- Defeated Leva Bates (SHINE 52)
Aja Perera (February 11, 2018-May 10, 2019)[]
- Defeated Candy Cartwright to become the new champion. (SHINE 54)
- Defeated Dementia D'Rose (SHINE 55)
- Defeated Kiera Hogan (SHINE 56)
- Defeated Stormie Lee (FIP Everything Burns 2019)
- Defeated Priscilla Kelly (EVOLVE 121)
- Defeated The Cutie Pie Club (Dementia D'Rose & Kiera Hogan) (SHINE 57)
Shotzi Blackheart (May 10, 2019-Current)[]
- Defeated Aja Perera to become the new champion. (SHINE 58)
- Defeated Aja Perera and Santana Garrett in a 3-Way Match (SHINE 59)