Return Engagement was a wrestling event promoted by Ring of Honor. It took place on April 19, 2008 at the Frontier Fieldhouse in Chicago Ridge, Illinois. The show's name comes from of its matches, with the Briscoe Brothers vs. the Motor City Machine Guns in a rematch from Good Times, Great Memories.
- Dark match: Danny Daniels & Rhett Titus defeated Ernie Osiris & Trik Davis
- Austin Aries defeated Silas Young
- After the match, Jimmy Jacobs came out and congratulated Aries on joining The Age of the Fall, but warned him to stay away from Lacey. Aries told Jacobs he didn't join The Age of the Fall, Lacey quit, and it was in his best interest to leave the two of them alone.
- This match was taped for ROH Videos.com.
- Mitch Franklin vs. Alex Payne ended in a no contest
- The match was stopped after Necro Butcher attacked both wrestlers.
- Necro Butcher defeated Mitch Franklin & Alex Payne in a Handicap match
- Claudio Castagnoli & Pelle Primeau defeated Sweet n' Sour Inc. (Adam Pearce & Brent Albright)
- Castagnoli pinned Albright after Pearce accidentally hit him with his briefcase, allowing Castagnoli to give him a Ricola Bomb.
- MsChif defeated Ashley Lane, Daizee Haze and Lacey in a Four Corner Survival match
- Chris Hero (w/Sweet n' Sour Inc.) defeated Delirious
- The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) defeated the Briscoe Brothers (Jay & Mark Briscoe)
- Kota Ibushi defeated El Generico
- The Age of the Fall (Tyler Black, Joey Matthews & Zach Gowen) defeated The Vulture Squad (Jack Evans, Ruckus & Jigsaw w/Julius Smokes)
- Jimmy Jacobs was originally scheduled to compete in the match, but replaced himself with Gowen.
- After the match, Jacobs called out Austin Aries. When he came out, he was attacked by The Age of the Fall, who held him down while Jacobs pulled out a spike. Lacey came down and threw herself on Aries, begging Jacobs to stop. Jacobs prepared to spike her, but broke down crying, allowing the two to walk away.
- Nigel McGuinness defeated Kevin Steen to retain the ROH World Championship
|Austin Aries vs. Silas Young|