- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- Adam Cole defeated Silas Young (8:39)
- Bobby Fish (w/ Kyle O'Reilly) defeated Tadarius Thomas (9:51)
- Charlie Haas defeated Rhett Titus (12:05)
- SCUM (Jimmy Jacobs & Steve Corino) & Rhino defeated Jay Lethal & The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe) (12:08)
- Matt Hardy defeated BJ Whitmer (12:20)
- Davey Richards defeated Kyle O'Reilly (19:00)
- Kevin Steen defeated Eddie Edwards and Michael Elgin and Roderick Strong in a Four Way Defy Or Deny Match (21:19)
- Roderick Strong eliminated Michael Elgin (15:53)
- Eddie Edwards & Eddie Edwards eliminated Roderick Strong (19:40)
- Kevin Steen eliminated Eddie Edwards (21:19)
|2013 Ring of Honor Events|
The Hunt for Gold • Defy or Deny 2 • Honor vs. Evil • 11th Anniversary Show • Supercard of Honor VII • Border Wars 2013 • Dragon's Reign • Relentless • Honor in the Heart of Texas • Live and Let Die • Best in the World 2013 • A Night of Hoopla • Reclamation - Day 1 • Reclamation - Day 2 • All Star Extravaganza V • Manhattan Mayhem V • Road to Greatness - Day 1 • Road to Greatness - Day 2 • Death before Dishonor XI • A New Dawn • Charm City Challenge • Glory by Honor XII • Final Battle 2013