The following title matches feature the NXT Heritage Cup Championship.
Title matches[]
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
2020[]
- November 26 - NXT UK: A-Kid defeated Trent Seven [2:1] [Round 7] (21:20)
- December 10 - NXT UK: A-Kid (c) defeated Tyler Bate [2:1] [Round 6] to retain (13:51)
2021[]
- February 18 - NXT UK: A-Kid (c) defeated Sha Samuels [2:1] [Round 5] to retain (11:23)
- May 20 - NXT UK: Tyler Bate (w/ Trent Seven) defeated A-Kid (c) [1:0] [Round 6] to win (15:58)
- July 1 - NXT UK: Tyler Bate (c) defeated Jack Starz [2:1] [Round 4] to retain (8:08)
- July 15 - NXT UK: Tyler Bate (c) defeated Mark Coffey [2:1] [Round 5] to retain (10:12)
- October 28 - NXT UK: Noam Dar defeated Tyler Bate (c) [2:1] [Round 6] to win (14:46)
- November 25 - NXT UK: Noam Dar (w/ Sha Samuels) (c) defeated Sam Gradwell [2:1] [Round 4] to retain (10:54)
2022[]
- January 20 - NXT UK: Noam Dar (w/ Sha Samuels) (c) vs. A-Kid for the NXT UK Heritage Cup Championship ended in a Draw [1:1] [Round 6] (18:00)
- March 10 - NXT UK: Noam Dar (c) defeated Joe Coffey [2:1] [Round 5] to retain (17:43)
- March 31 - NXT UK: Noam Dar (c) (w/Sha Samuels) defeated Mark Coffey (w/Joe Coffey) [Round 5] to retain (16:46)
- July 14 - NXT UK: Mark Coffey defeated Noam Dar (c) [2:1] [Round 6] to win
- August 25 - NXT UK: Noam Dar (w/Sha Samuels) defeated Mark Coffey (c) [2:1] [Round 6] to win
2023[]
- May 28 - Battleground: Noam Dar (c) defeated Dragon Lee [2:1] [Round 5] to retain
- June 13 - NXT: Nathan Frazer (w/Dragon Lee) defeated Oro Mensah (w/Lash Legend, Jakara Jackson & Noam Dar) [2:1] [Round 4] to win
- June 27 - NXT Gold Rush - Week 2: Nathan Frazer (w/Yulisa Leon) (c) defeated Dragon Lee (w/Valentina Feroz) [2:1] [Round 5] to retain
- August 22 - NXT Heat Wave: Noam Dar (w/Oro Mensah, Lash Legend & Jakara Jackson) defeated Nathan Frazer (w/Tyler Bate) (c) [2:1] [Round 6] to win
- September 30 - No Mercy: Noam Dar (c) defeated Butch [2:1] [Round 6] to retain
- November 7 - NXT: Noam Dar (w/Oro Mensah, Lash Legend & Jakara Jackson) (c) defeated Akira Tozawa (w/Chad Gable, Otis & Maxxine Dupri) [2:1] [Round 5] to retain
- November 21 - NXT: Noam Dar (w/Oro Mensah, Lash Legend & Jakara Jackson) (c) vs. Chad Gable (w/Otis, Maxxine Dupri & Akira Tozawa) ended in a Draw [1:1] [Round 6]. Dar retains.
- December 26 - NXT: Noam Dar (w/Oro Mensah, Lash Legend & Jakara Jackson) (c) defeated Josh Briggs by DQ to retain
2024[]
- January 30 - NXT: Noam Dar (w/Oro Mensah, Lash Legend & Jakara Jackson) (c) defeated Von Wagner (w/Mr. Stone) [2:0] [Round 4] to retain
- February 27 - NXT: Charlie Dempsey defeated Noam Dar (c) [2:1] [Round 5] to win
- March 19 - NXT: Drew Gulak (c) defeated Riley Osborne [2:1] [Round 4] to retain
- May 14 - NXT: Tony D'Angelo defeated Charlie Dempsey (c) [2:1] [Round 5] to win
- June 4 - NXT: Tony D'Angelo (c) defeated Damon Kemp [2:0] [Round 4] to retain
- June 25 - NXT: Tony D'Angelo (c) defeated Nathan Frazer [2:1] [Round 6] to retain
- July 9 - NXT: Tony D'Angelo (c) defeated Lexis King [2:1] [Round 4] to retain
- July 30 - The Great American Bash: Tony D'Angelo (c) defeated Tavion Heights [2:1] [Round 5] to retain
- August 13 - NXT: Charlie Dempsey defeated Tony D'Angelo (c) [2:1] [Round 5] to win
- September 10 - NXT: Charlie Dempsey (c) defeated Je'Von Evans [2:1] [Round 5] to retain
- October 29 - NXT: Charlie Dempsey (c) defeated Lexis King [2:0] [Round 3] to retain
- December 24 - NXT: Lexis King defeated Charlie Dempsey (c) [1:0] [Round 4] to win