2012
- August 29 - Seth Rollins defeated Jinder Mahal to become the inaugural champion
- October 10 - Seth Rollins (c) defeated Michael McGillicutty
- December 12 - Seth Rollins (c) defeated Jinder Mahal
2013
- January 2 - Corey Graves defeated Seth Rollins (c) via Disqualification
- January 9 - Big E. Langston defeated Seth Rollins (c)
- April 3 - Big E. Langston (c) defeated Conor O'Brian
- April 24 - Big E. Langston (c) defeated Brad Maddox
- May 15 - Big E. Langston (c) defeated Damien Sandow
- June 12 - Bo Dallas defeated Big E. Langston (c)
- July 3 - Bo Dallas (c) defeated Antonio Cesaro
- August 7 - Bo Dallas (c) defeated Leo Kruger
- October 16 - Bo Dallas (c) defeated Sami Zayn
2014
- February 27 - NXT Arrival: Adrian Neville defeated Bo Dallas (c) in a Ladder Match
- March 20 - (NXT) - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Bo Dallas
- May 1 - (NXT) - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Brodus Clay in a No Disqualification Match
- May 29 - NXT Takeover - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Tyson Kidd
- June 12 - (NXT) - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Tyson Kidd (with Natalya)
- July 31 - (NXT) - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Tyler Breeze via Disqualification
- September 11 - NXT TakeOver: Fatal Four Way - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Tyson Kidd, Tyler Breeze, and Sami Zayn in a Fatal Four Way Match
- October 2 - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Tyson Kidd in a Last Chance Match
- November 13 - (NXT) - Adrian Neville (c) defeated Sami Zayn
- December 11 - NXT Takeover: Revolution - Sami Zayn defeated Adrian Neville (c) in a Title vs. Career Match
2015
- February 11 - NXT Takeover: Rival - Kevin Owens defeated Sami Zayn (c) via Referee Stoppage to win the NXT Championship
- March 25 - (NXT) - Kevin Owens (c) defeated Finn Balor
- May 14 (NXT Live Event) - Kevin Owens (c) defeated Finn Balor and Tyler Breeze in a Triple Threat Match
- May 15 (NXT Live Event) - Finn Balor defeated Kevin Owens (c) via Disqualification
- May 20 - NXT Takeover: Unstoppable - Kevin Owens (c) vs. Sami Zayn ends in a draw
- July 4 - WWE Beast in the East - Finn Balor defeats Kevin Owens (c)
- August 22 - NXT Takeover: Brooklyn - Finn Balor (c) defeats Kevin Owens in a Ladder Match
- December 16 - NXT Takeover: London - Finn Balor (c) defeats Samoa Joe
2016
- April 1 - NXT Takeover: Dallas - Finn Balor (c) defeated Samoa Joe
- April 21 - NXT House Show - Samoa Joe defeated Finn Bálor (c) to win the championship
- June 8 - NXT TakeOver: The End - Samoa Joe (c) defeated Finn Bálor in a Steel Cage match to retain the championship
- August 20 - NXT TakeOver: Back to Brooklyn: Shinsuke Nakamura defeated Samoa Joe (c) to win the championship
- November 19 - NXT TakeOver: Toronto: Samoa Joe defeated Shinsuke Nakamura (c) to win the Championship
- December 3 - NXT House Show: Shinsuke Nakamura defeated Samoa Joe (c) to win the Championship
2017
- January 28 - NXT TakeOver: San Antonio: Bobby Roode defeated Shinsuke Nakamura (c) to win the Championship
- April 1 - NXT TakeOver: Orlando: Bobby Roode (c) defeated Shinsuke Nakamura to retain the championship
- May 20 - NXT TakeOver: Chicago: Bobby Roode (c) defeated Hideo Itami to retain the championship
- August 19 - NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn III: Drew McIntyre defeated Bobby Roode (c) to win the championship
- November 18 - NXT TakeOver: WarGames: Andrade Almas (w/Zelina Vega) defeated Drew McIntyre (c) to win the championship
2018
- January 27 - NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia: Andrade Almas (c) (w/Zelina Vega) defeated Johnny Gargano to retain the Championship.
- February 24 - WWE NXT: Andrade Almas (c) (with Zelina Vega) defeated Johnny Gargano in a Title vs. NXT Career Match to retain the Championship.
- April 7 - NXT TakeOver: New Orleans: Aleister Black defeated Andrade Almas (c) (with Zelina Vega) to win the Championship.
- June 16 - NXT TakeOver: Chicago II: Aleister Black (c) defeated Lars Sullivan to retain the Championship.
- July 18 - (NXT) - Tommaso Ciampa defeated Aleister Black (c) to win the Championship.
- August 18 - NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4: Tommaso Ciampa (c) defeated Johnny Gargano in a Last Man Standing Match to retain the Championship.
- November 17 - NXT TakeOver: WarGames II: Tommaso Ciampa (c) defeated The Velveteen Dream to retain the Championship.
2019
- January 27 - NXT TakeOver: Phoenix: Tommaso Ciampa (c) defeated Aleister Black to retain the Championship.
- April 5 - NXT TakeOver: New York: Johnny Gargano defeated Adam Cole in a 2-out-of-3 Falls match to win the vacant Championship.
- June 1 - NXT TakeOver: XXV: Adam Cole defeated Johnny Gargano (c) to win the Championship.