The show opened with Scott D'Amore being interviewed. Tommy Dreamer interrupted the interview to remind him that a #1 Contender for Kenny Omega's Impact World Championship still hasn't been chosen, and Scott decided to leave the decision up to him.
The first match had The Good Brothers face Chris Bey & Jay White. Karl & Gallows came out on top after a Magic Killer on Bey. Backstage, Fire 'N Flava were talking about how they were going to get the Knockouts Tag Team Championships back, when Fallah Bahh interrupted them to ask Tasha to be his partner at Homecoming, which she accepted.
Next up, Kaleb with a K, accompanied by Tenille Dashwood, faced Taylor Wilde in an intergender match. Wilde nailed an inverted frankensteiner and followed with a bridging german suplex to get the win. Chris Bey and Jay White talked backstage about their loss. White said that Bey doesn't deserve to be a member of the Bullet Club after that, but he offered him a "chance at redemption".
Josh Alexander said he wanted more matches, so Scott D'Amore arrived and announced that he'd defend his X-Division Championship against Black Taurus at Homecoming. Deonna Purrazzo then had an interview where she revealed that she was training with Invicta FC Atomweight Champion Alesha Zappitella for her appearance at NWA, and also that she'll compete at Homecoming, though she didn't reveal her partner.
Next was an 8-man tag team match where Fallah Bahh, No Way & FinJuice went up against Ace Austin, Madman Fulton, Rohit Raju & Shera. Finlay got the win for his team by hitting the Trash Panda on Rohit.
Kenny Omega and Don Callis were having an interview when Tommy Dreamer interrupted to announce that they were having a #1 Contender's battle royale, and the winner would face Omega at Emergence. A vignette teasing the arrival of the "Drama King" played, and after that FinJuice tried to cut a promo, but were assaulted by Chris Bey and Jay White.
The Elite made their way to the ring, and Sami Callihan then walked out as well to reveal that next week, he and two partners were going to face The Good Brothers and Kenny Omega in a match. Frankie Kazarian then rushed to the ring and scared The Elite off! Backstage, Kaz and Callihan talked to Tommy Dreamer and suggested that he be the third member of the team, he refused and whispered a suggestion to them, though Callihan wasn't happy about it.
There was a creepy vignette with Su Yung, with her telling a seemingly possessed Kimber Lee that "her time has come". Sam Beale tried to get his mentor Brian Myers to team with former ECW stars Beulah McGillycutty and Francine at Homecoming, but to no avail.
Next, Violent By Design (Deaner & Rhino, with Eric Young & Joe Doering) faced Rich Swann & Willie Mack in a tag team match. A stunner from Mack to Rhino allowed Rich to follow with a 450 splash and win the match.
Matt Cardona and Chelsea Green arrived at Swinger's Palace to talk about Homecoming, and Alisha decided to tag with Hernandez. After Petey Williams and Jordynne Grace came in imitating Scott Steiner, W. Morrisey then appeared to kill the mood and warn Alisha of what he was going to do with her husband. Eddie then had an interview where he talked about what just happened, and Tommy Dreamer interrupted it to talk him into being Callihan and Kazarian's partner.
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- The Good Brothers (Karl Anderson & Doc Gallows) defeated Jay White & Chris Bey (8:54)
- Taylor Wilde defeated Kaleb with a K (w/ Tenille Dashwood) (4:11)
- FinJuice (David Finlay & Juice Robinson), Fallah Bahh & No Way defeated Ace Austin, Madman Fulton, Rohit Raju & Mahabali Shera in an Eight Man Tag Team Match (6:43)
- Rich Swann & Willie Mack defeated Violent By Design (Deaner & Rhino) (w/ Eric Young & Joe Doering) (10:38)
- Moose defeated Chris Sabin (8:24)
Other on-screen talent