Nicole Savoy (April 2, 2016-July 8, 2017)[]
- Defeated Candice LeRae and Heidi Lovelace to become the inaugural champion (SHIMMER Vol. 80)
- Defeated Crazy Mary Dobson (SHIMMER Vol. 81)
- Defeated Ryo Mizunami (SHIMMER Vol. 82)
- Defeated Shayna Baszler (SHIMMER Vol. 83)
- Defeated Jessicka Havok (SHIMMER Vol. 84)
- Defeats Kay Lee Ray (SHIMMER Vol. 85)
Shazza McKenzie (July 8, 2017-present)[]
- Defeated Nicole Savoy to become new champion (SHIMMER Vol. 93)
- Defeated Courtney Rush (SHIMMER Vol. 94)
- Defeated Nicole Matthews (SHIMMER Vol. 95)