|Harry Smith||1||June 26, 2007||Tampa, Florida||Won a 21-man battle royal to become the first champion.|
|Afa, Jr.||1||October 16, 2007||New Port Richey, Florida||Declared winner when Harry Smith could not make referee's ten count.|
|TJ Wilson||1||December 1, 2007||New Port Richey, Florida||This was a Ladder match.|
|Ted DiBiase, Jr.||1||December 18, 2007||New Port Richey, Florida||N/A.|
|Heath Miller||1||January 19, 2008||New Port Richey, Florida||Awarded title when his partner Ted DiBiase, Jr. was unable to defend it due to injury.|
|Jake Hager||1||March 22, 2008||New Port Richey, Florida||Unified with the FCW Florida Heavyweight Championship|
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.