Professional wrestling career
Independent circuit (2018–2020)
All Elite Wrestling (2020–present)
Jay made her first appearance in All Elite Wrestling on April 1, 2020, losing to Hikaru Shida in singles competition on Dynamite. On April 6, she had signed with the company. Following a loss in singles competition to Abadon on the June 17 episode of Dynamite, she was helped backstage by The Dark Order. Jay teamed with Tay Conti in AEW Women's Tag Team Cup Tournament: The Deadly Draw. They advanced in the quarterfinals by defeating Nyla Rose and Ariane Andrew but lost to Ivelisse and Diamante during the semifinals. She was officially introduced as a member of The Dark Order on the August 27 episode of Dynamite. On the November 25 episode of Dynamite Jay challenged Shida for the AEW Women's World Championship which Jay lost.
Luchas de Apuestas record
|Winner (wager)||Loser (wager)||Location||Event||Date|
|Anna Jayy (hair)||Thunder Blonde (hair)||Canton, Georgia||GPW Edge of Darkness||January 17, 2020
- "The Star of the Show"